Monday, February 20, 2017

2017 KIUC Board Election - Please Vote For Me

Last week the 2017 Kauai Island Utility Cooperative (KIUC) board election ballots were mailed to members.  The deadline to submit your ballot by mail or electronically is by noon, Saturday, March 18, 2107.  Please vote for me - Mahalo, Mina

Why Am I Running For the KIUC Board?


I want to serve our Kauai community by using my past experience. For over 19 years, as a politician and regulator, I have held leadership roles in energy policy development and utility regulation. If given the privilege and honor to serve the cooperative, I will use this experience to work collaboratively with other board members and our community to strategically shape and sustain our cooperative to provide excellent electricity service and value for our Kauai community.

But while there is always ample coverage about renewable energy generation, it is only one part of the total energy system equation. To help to keep rates from increasing we must keep costs under control, increase productivity and efficiency, make wise investments and seek some growth. My primary objective is to advocate for accessibility, fairness and opportunity for all members to benefit from clean energy policies and programs to manage their electricity bills.  As the coop delves into modernizing the electric system, our community needs to understand the technical and economic challenges to do so, therefore, I view educating and engaging coop members to be an important responsibility of a board member and an important component to advance Kauai's clean energy transformation.

I also believe a well-round board which seeks experience, gender and geographic diversity will benefit our cooperative and its democratic principles.

A Little About Me

I was born and raised on Lanai, where my father was the game warden and my mother a pineapple field worker.  After graduating from Kamehameha, I attended the University of Hawaii briefly then moved to work in Washington, D.C. for U.S. Senator Hiram Fong.  When I returned to Hawaii, I was offered a job at Princeville.  I have called Hanalei Valley home since 1977 where my husband, Lance, raised our two daughters.  We now have four granddaughters (ages 11, 9, 9 and 3) and like all families worry about our children and grandchildren's future and ability to survive the high cost of living on Kauai.  

What I Can Contribute

As a State Representative, I authored and led the enactment of many of the state’s most significant laws that has shaped Hawaii’s energy landscape.  As a regulator (Chair of the Hawaii Public Utilities Commission), I had to learn and understand all parts of the electric utility business from financing, engineering to operations.  My practical experience and success in building consensus positions with my peers (legislators and fellow commissioners), the public, public utilities and other special interests throughout my political/public service career, I think, can be of benefit as a member of the board.

What I Will Commit To

As a regulator I embraced three objectives to help guide my decisions.  I believe the following objectives, which I will commit to, can also be applied to important decisions a KIUC board member must make on strategies to advance Kauai electric system to benefit its customers/members.  

#1 - Lower, more stable electric bills for all customers through a strategy of a diverse portfolio of resources and technologies by encouraging prudent timing for new investments to optimize all assets, whether utility or customer-based, to achieve efficiency, cost-effective benefits and value to Kauai’s electric system.

#2 – To balance the maximum use of cost-effective renewable energy resources while protecting the electrical system performance to maintain reliability in a rapidly changing system operating environment.

#3 – Advocate for accessibility, fairness and opportunity for all electricity customers/members to benefit from clean energy policies and programs to manage their electricity bills. 

Work Experience (partial)

Current                        Blog, Energy Dynamics
                                      Energy Consultant

Mar 2011-Jan 2015      Chairperson/Commissioner, Hawaii Public Utilities Commission

Nov 1996-Mar 2011     Hawaii State Representative, Hawaii State House of Representatives
                                        1999-2011 Chair, House Committee on Energy & Environmental Protection

1994-1997                     Business Manager, Kilauea Point Natural History Association

1990-1994                     Business Manager, Kong Lung Store/Kong Lung Center

Other Experience

Current                        Board Member, Hale Halawai O Hanalei (The Hanalei Community Center)
                                      Member, Hawaii Energy Policy Forum

1993-1996                     Commissioner, Kauai Police Commission

1990-1993                     Commissioner, Kauai Planning Commission

Publications

Co-Author - Clean Energy from the Earth, Wind and Sun:  Learning from Hawaii's Search for a Renewable Energy Strategy, William S. Pintz and Hermina Morita, published by Springer, December 2016. (http://www.springer.com/us/book/9783319486765)

Contributor - Infrastructure Risk Management:  Assessing and Managing Dynamic
Exogenous Risk, authored a chapter entitled, “Designing Regulation Around Technological 
Innovation:  Experiences from Hawaii,” PEI Alternative Insights, June 2015.

Researcher, Interviewer, Photographer - Center for Oral History, Social Science Research Institute,
University of Hawaii at Manoa’s  project Lanai Ranch:  The People of Koele and Keomuku
published in July 1989.



Wednesday, January 11, 2017

2017 Legislative Session Opens January 18

Preceding the opening of the 2017 Hawaii Legislature on Wednesday, January 18, the Hawaii Energy Policy Forum will be holding its annual legislative briefing tomorrow, January 12, 1:30 to 4:30 p.m. with the theme, "Finding Continuity:  Whatever Happened To . . . ?"

The keynote speaker will be Gavin Bade, the Washington, D.C. based Editor of Utility Dive.  Utility Dive describes itself as a provider of news and analysis for energy and utility executives covering topics like energy technology and trends, regulation, policy and politics.  He has been asked to give an analysis of the national energy situation under a new administration and what bodes for Hawaii.

Mr. Bade was a speaker/participant in the 2016 Maui Energy Conference and he and other Utility Dive writers have been providing thoughtful and thorough analysis on Hawaii's clean energy quest. In yesterday's Utility Dive, Mr. Bade writes about Kauai Island Utility Cooperative's (KIUC) signed deal with AES Corporation for a dispatchable solar/storage project at 11 cents/kWh.

In the Hawaii energy realm, a big topic as the 2017 legislature opens will be energy storage. Solar installers will be lobbying lawmakers for energy storage tax credit primarily for systems sited with residential rooftop solar systems. Recently, the Department of Taxation released its 2016 annual report on tax credits for the Tax Year 2014.  In their best estimates, $112,130,000.00 was paid out in Renewable Energy Income Tax Credit (REITC), comprising 35.2% of all tax credits paid.  It is likely that the same taxpayers that benefited from the REITC will be the same taxpayers to benefit from an energy storage tax credit.

While the Honolulu Star-Advertiser continually laments about the collapsing numbers of new solar installation, when will lawmakers stop and think about Hawaii residents who are not benefiting from our current clean energy policies but are subsidizing, through electricity rates and tax credits paid out of the States general fund these largely out of state corporate solar entities who are installing systems that are producing electricity when there is no demand?

On Kauai, KIUC negotiated deals, with no state subsidies, to buy electricity a lower cost through dispatchable solar/storage contracts to benefit its operating system and entire customer base lowering cost.  On the other hand, for the rest of the State, solar companies will be showing up at the Legislature to ask for more handouts just to give more benefits to the individuals who already have benefited from lucrative and highly subsidized policies like net energy metering and the renewable energy income tax credit and then forcing the Hawaiian Electric Companies to buy back electricity at present high and uncompetitive rates adversely affecting its customers without rooftop solar.

We are way beyond the need for renewable energy generation policies to develop and subsidize nascent concepts and technologies - it time to move on and to ensure that public and ratepayer monies are used to make the critical investments for a robust electricity grid/platform to advance the public good and not step into areas where competitive markets should be established.

Wednesday, November 9, 2016

Trump + Energy = An Uncertain Future

Last night I could not bear to watch or listen to the presidential election results.  After a sleepless night, it was time to confront my fears, a Trump presidency with a Republican congress.

For the past year, I have been watching the Hawaii clean energy initiative deteriorate to a mishmash of just stuff with sound bites.  Unfortunately, there is nothing being said or done to create the needed vision for a cohesive implementation strategy for a systemic energy transformation.  Yes, you have a bunch of politicians chanting 100% renewable energy but that's all you have.  Quite frankly, after championing energy issues for my 20-years in public service, then watching it all fall apart (except for Kauai) over the past year, it has been difficult to blog about Hawaii's energy future as I find it so uninspiring now.

Waking up this morning, like Hawaii, the decarbonization of our nation's energy sector faces an uncertain future.  While I may still find it difficult to write about energy issues, there are people like Gavin Bade, the editor of Utility Dive doing this important work to keep the public informed.  Today he reveals energy Trumpisms, giving insight to this new administration's energy ideology in "All bets are off: 4 takeaways on what President Trump means for the power sector."

Wednesday, September 28, 2016

Hanging in Balance

Hawaii's clean energy systems is a delicate balance of power, literally and figuratively.

Literally, each second of each day, Hawaii's electric utilities must carefully manage the supply of electrons coming from many different sources to provide safe, affordable and reliable electricity to match their customer's usage to balance the grid to avoid brownouts or blackouts.

Figuratively, there is a carefully crafted balance of power between the executive, legislative and
judicial branches of government in the Hawaii State Constitution.  A decision by Judge Edwin Nacino, outlined in a August 26 minute order and a subsequent September 19 judgment, which ruled in favor of placing Thomas Gorack on the Hawaii Public Utilities Commission and dismissed all other counts throws this balance of power off-kilter.  Seemingly, the judgement places a finger on one side of the scale leaving more questions than answers as the ruling was contrary to well settled principles, previous attorney general opinions and the legal definition of "vacancy."

In part, Judge Nacino's minute order ruled:
. . . the Court accepts defendants' arguments which included that a vacancy occurred upon the expiration of Mr. Champley's term of office.  Thus, the Court finds Governor Ige's interim appointment of Mr. Gorack when the Senate was not in session to be valid and subject to all other limitations found in Article V, Section 6, paragraph 5 of the Hawaii Constitution.
There is no disagreement on the Governor's constitutionally given power to make an interim appointment when there is a vacancy and the Senate is not in session, however, a change in the legal definition of what constitutes a vacancy may now open the door to an abuse of power if the Governor shirks his or her responsibility to timely submit future nominations of public utility commissioners or for other boards and commissions to avoid the Senate's constitutional given right to give its advice and consent before an appointment is made.

This whole case turns on the plain language of one word - vacancy.  My attorney, the former Attorney General, Mark Bennett, and I continue to contend that, despite the fact that Commissioner Michael Champley's term had expired, the office did not become vacant because (1) the constitution grants the Legislature the power to make laws governing terms and removal of members of boards and commissions not specifically address in the Hawaii constitution, (2) the Legislature, wanting to avoid a vacancy, did pass a law stating that the incumbent Commissioner shall serve (beyond the expiration of his/her term) until his/her successor is appointed and qualified and (3) the phase "appointed and qualified" includes the requirement for the Senate to give its advice and consent on a nominee and, until Senate confirmation, the holdover Commissioner remains as the officer de jure, a person who is legally entitled to remain in that position even though the term had expired.

Although the legislative intent of past constitutional conventions and previous attorney general opinions were presented and argued in the Senate's amicus curiae and plaintiff's filings, the Judge's ruling did not offer a deep dive into nor did it make any kind of determination on the constitutionality of the holdover provision in State law nor did it question the power given to the Legislature to define the terms and removal members of boards and commission for positions not specifically addressed in the constitution but delegated to the Legislature.

In my opinion, if the Constitution and statute were correctly interpreted, as it was prior to this suspect "appointment," Governor Ige would have two options (1) make a timely nomination during the legislative session to receive the Senate's advice and consent where the appointed and qualified nominee would assume the office on July 1 upon the expiration of a board member or commissioner's term; or (2) call the Senate back into session during the interim to consider a potential nomination to receive the Senate's advice and consent where the incumbent Commissioner would step down upon the nominee receiving Senate confirmation.

Conversely, using Governor Ige's arguments in this lawsuit and now with Judge Nacino's ruling, the Governor office can abuse its power and can now easily avoid the responsibility of making timely nominations during the regular legislative session thereby avoiding the Senate's right to advice and consent and replace people on boards and commissions on July 1 (terms usually end on June 30), allowing his candidate sit without scrutiny until the following legislative session.

We all should be concerned about this unchecked power which Judge Nacino's ruling gave to Governor Ige as it affects other boards and commissions too.  But more so and ironically, the Public Utilities Commission's unique authority, which includes administrative, quasi-judicial and policy responsibilities, is conveyed to it by Legislative action and approval.  As an agency that must be independent, the PUC should be viewed as an extension of the Legislature, not a department under the Executive branch.  This is the primary reason why the Senate's advice and consent regarding Public Utility Commissioners is important with a requirement in law that a PUC commissioner to holdover until his or her successor is confirmed by the Senate.










Wednesday, July 27, 2016

Solar Politics In Nevada

Utility Dive's Editor, Gavin Bade, is covering the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC) conference in Nashville, Tennessee this week and writes about a speech given by Nevada PUC Commissioner, David Noble, who headed up Nevada's net-metering proceedings and who was not reappointed by Governor Sandoval.  I am sorry to see Nevada lose a good commissioner who, in trying to make good regulatory decisions based on facts, stood up to toxic personalities like the fired and ousted Bryan Miller, the former Senior Vice President of Public Policy for Sunrun and former spokesperson for The Alliance for Solar Choice (TASC). 

Bade reports:
While press reports and solar lobbyists painted the decision as a “disastrous” for the rooftop industry, Noble said it was the solar industry that failed to constructively engage with the regulatory process. 
“One of the problems in the case before us is the rooftop solar companies decided to take an approach of an all-or-nothing, and basically promoted that there should be no change from retail rates,” he told fellow regulators. “When you take an all-or-nothing approach there's a possibility you're going to lose and that's exactly what happened because they put on an inferior case.” 
While Noble said he would have made the comments regardless, Utility Dive learned Gov. Brian Sandoval (R) will not reappoint him to another term at the end of this year — a fact the governor’s office confirmed to Utility Dive this morning. 
“I just caution all commissioners to listen to all sides but be very wary,” Noble said. “Words are one thing, actions are another.”
Commissioner Noble gives the backstory to the Nevada solar-net metering proceedings.  A must read for people who want to hear a different perspective than the aggressive, scripted and coordinated political positions of these types of businesses and organizations like TASC, which are self-serving.

Tuesday, July 19, 2016

Battle Fatigue: Time to Get To Work/Put Up or Shut Up

For a long time, Governor Ige and State Representative Chris Lee have intimated that there are other parties interested in purchasing the HECO Companies.  The Hawaii Public Utilities Commission own order (page 263) stated, "The HECO Companies' attributes that were attractive to NextEra are still available to other potential suitors."

This afternoon the Board of Directors of Hawaiian Electric Industries (HEI) made it clear in a press release that it is not interested in sizing up potential suitors:
The business and affairs of HEI are managed under the direction of its boards of directors.  In accordance with its fiduciary duties, the boards have determined that it is in the best interests of the company and all of the stakeholders that it serves – including shareholders, customers, employees and communities – to remain independent and to work toward realizing the clean energy future and vibrant local economy we all want for Hawaii.  In this regard, and despite statements reported in the media about other unnamed parties rumored to be interested in acquiring HEI, the company is not currently in discussions with any other party regarding a business combination and does not intend to initiate any such discussions.
Simply put, politicians and regulators should not be in the matchmaking business to effect a forced marriage on a private business.  If certain politicians and the regulator are not happy with the performance of the HECO Companies and its control and operations of Hawaii's electricity franchises then Legislators should use their legislative powers to revoke the franchises and put them up for auction rather than to keep pressing suitors on an unwilling seller.

Rather than seek the limelight and press coverage to just offer intimations, if these politicians think there are better ownership/business model options then they should be held accountable to outline the framework and the follow-up actions to use the State's revocation and condemnation powers to start an adversarial proceeding for a takeover of the electricity system.  And, did I say . . . be held accountable for their actions and subsequent decisions.

The HECO-NextEra merger Order states, "As part of their statutory mandate, the HECO Companies must continue to operate to provide safe, reliable, reasonably priced electric service, while meeting the challenges of the current market in general and the various State renewable energy goals in particular."  The Order also states, "In the commission's view, the time has come for the HECO Companies to finalize and put into action their plans for achieving the State's clean energy transformation."  However, the sentence before that says, "Although there has been progress on each of these issues [dockets on power system improvement plan, distributed energy resources, demand response programs, community solar], the commission observes that progress by the HECO Companies has been very slow."

In general, decision and orders coming from the Commission itself has been very slow.  Perhaps certain politicians should be more concerned about and investigate the dysfunction within the Commission and the questionable occupation of a commissioner's seat rather than matchmaking for the HECO Companies.

Monday, July 18, 2016

HEI Stock Takes A Hit - Nexit: A Big Puka To Fill

Given its perverse political and regulatory climate, it should not be a surprise that NextEra Energy is exiting Hawaii. The downward decline in Hawaiian Electric Industries' stock price shown below correlates to Governor Ige's appointment of Tom Gorack on June 29, the release of the Hawaii Public Utilities Commission (HPUC) Order on Friday and NextEra's subsequent exit early this morning. Between the period of June 29 and 4 p.m. today, when the stock market closed, my estimate of local value destruction (shares with Hawaii ties) is around $120,000,000. 

I wrote a post on July 1 on the fallout of the Gorack appointment. What I said is worth repeating as the PUC's actions and NextEra's exit are no longer speculative, resulting in value destruction affecting Hawaii shareholders and the likelihood of higher financing costs which, ultimately, will be passed on to electricity customers.
. . . given HECO's weakening financial position and lacking a stabilizing factor like NextEra's financial strength, the future outlook does not bode well given all this uncertainty. Prior to the merger application, HECO's credit rating by Standards and Poor was BBB-, one notch above non-investment grade.  The merger application stabilized HECO's credit worthiness with a neutral outlook given NextEra's strong financial position.  With Hawaii's unstable regulatory and unfriendly business climate, and without a strong financial partner, there could be a propensity to affect HECO's credit rating downward, without any cushion or safety net, it would be to non-investment grade level. 
Who pays for the additional cost for these added risks of regulatory uncertainty and financial instability - the HECO customer - in HECO having to pay higher interest rates for access to capital thereby resulting in higher electricity costs.
Like Brexit, it is much too late for regrets.  Without a clear pathway to ensure a stable business climate and an improved regulatory environment, the damage will be ongoing with increased costs passed on to electricity customers.  With Nexit now in place, the $60 million in rate credits and potential $1 billion in state-wide benefits that the Hawaii Public Utilities Commission refused to acknowledge disappears. What remains is the price tag for the needed infrastructure improvements to realize the State renewable energy goals with no corresponding savings to help offset the price tag. There is no Plan B by the PUC/Ige Administration on how to recover these customer savings offsets except to hope for a generous suitor to appear.

Governor Ige comment on the PUC's Order stated:
No matter who owns the company, the energy vision for Hawaii remains clear - 100 percent renewable energy with a transformation to a customer-centered utility focusing on smart meters, smart grid, distributed local solutions, and as much consumer choice as possible.
Who owns the company does matter to give Hawaii the best chance for success by minimizing risk, maintaining service accessible and reliable and keeping rates affordable.  Linear thinking and relying on mantra-like soundbites like "100% renewables" or "no-fossil fuels" or even "local values" or "local ownership" does the public a disservice, as it is vague and insufficient to convey the difficulty and reality of the technical challenges and the cost and effort that will be required to attain such a future.

One's vision must align with the practical realities of execution and with one's values on how to achieve the vision with integrity.  Nexit created a big implementation puka for Hawaii's 100% renewable vision to fill.